Wednesday, September 23, 2009
What is "Insurance"?
Most people I know who are uninsured or paying over 20% of their income (myself) for health insurance would be glad to pay anything less than $5000 before subsidies kick in; it would decrease my bill. We are really healthy, and we pay $7200 in annual premiums for an individual plan....one that also jacks up our rates without warning on a seemingly random basis. When I am struggling to pay my bills every month, what keeps me up at night is this decision:
1. Do I be "responsible" and fork over 20% of my income to my insurance company, leaving me with no savings and barely able to pay my bills, or 2. take my chances that I won't get sick, risking not only bankruptcy but also the risk that if I get diagnosed with something during my time without coverage or with crappy coverage, I will never be able to get affordable coverage for anyone ever again?
I'm not worried about being burdened by taxes. I'm worried about being abandoned by an insurance company that is supposed to "insure" my well-being and being abandoned by my fellow citizens who don't see us as all in this together.
Preamble to the US Constitution:
We the people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
I look forward to my socialized Medicare when I get older, and have hope we can find a way to ensure no one loses everything because, and on top of the fact that, they became ill or injured or just old! I'm not saying the plan is perfect as-is, but let's examine our intentions....are we poo-pooing anything our political opponents put out there, or are we trying to think creatively together as fellow citizens?
Remember: there is more to this legislation, including provision that the insurance companies must cover everyone regardless of pre-existing conditions. With more people to cover overall (only achieved by making currently healthy people get covered), that will help them make up the differences in taking on the expensive, unhealthy people who need and deserve health care. And by ensuring everyone preventive coverage, we'll spend less on expensive ER visits and emergency surgeries that cheaper, preventive care could have, well, prevented.
The above is in response this original email, subject "And here's your tax increase":
OBAMACARE: LOSING EVERYONE
By DICK MORRIS & EILEEN MCGANN
Published in the New York Post on September 21, 2009
The elderly were the first group to turn against President Obama's health-care pro posals, alienated by the plans to cut $500 billion cut from Medicare. The young and the uninsured may be the next to jump ship -- out of worry over about the huge premiums they'd have to pay.
Requiring everyone to buy insurance will impose a massive tax on all who now are uninsured. The Congressional Budget Office projects that it would force the middle-income uninsured to pay on average more than 15 percent of their income.
The poor will still have Medicaid. But for those earning more, the required premiums will be worse than any tax increase. For example, CBO estimates that when the program is fully implemented -- by 2016 -- an individual earning $32,400 a year would have to pay $4,100 in premiums before getting any subsidy. With deductibles and co-payments, he'd have to shell out $5,600 a year, or 17.3 percent of his income. A family of four, making $80,000 a year, would have to pay about $10,500 in premiums alone -- with deductibles and co-payments, up to $15,000 or just under 20 percent of income.
And if they don't buy insurance, they'll face federal fines that begin to approach these same premium levels. They won't be able to buy what they truly need -- catastrophic-only coverage at a lower premium -- that won't satisfy ObamaCare's "minimum insurance" mandate.
The young and uninsured will catch on: This bill is designed to force healthy people who don't have health insurance -- and may neither need nor want it -- to buy it anyway, in order to raise the money to subsidize those who do need it.
Obama has pledged only to increase taxes on the rich. But his program essentially taxes the core of the middle class (those making $30,000 to $80,000). It will make them overpay in order to pick up the slack for others who need the extra coverage.
In other words, health-care "reform" is a health-care tax dressed up as a program to cover the uninsured.
No matter how Democrats get the money to cover those who need insurance, they offend supporters that they need to pass the bill:
* If they get the money from more Medicare cuts, they alienate the elderly still further.
* If they get it from raising the deficit, they lose moderates.
* If they hike taxes to do it, they lose the "Blue Dog" Democrats who've gone on record as opposing such increases.
* If they don't increase the subsidies, they lose the uninsured themselves.
The latest data from Scott Rasmussen's poll of those who lack health insurance indicates that they're starting to turn skeptical about the Obama plan. It's supposed to help them, yet they back it by only 58 percent to 35 percent -- and only 30 percent support it strongly.
More to the point, only 35 percent feel it will improve the quality of their health care -- and, by 41-26, they feel the cost of their care will go up, not down, under the plan.
Having the uninsured -- the stated object of Obama's compassion -- turn against his reform would be the most lethal cut of all.
Sunday, September 13, 2009
Prisoners have a right to health care. So should everyone else.
Nikki White died at the age of 32. She had lupus, a chronic inflammatory disease that was untreated because she could not afford health insurance.
The Body Count at Home
In the debate over health care, here’s an inequity to ponder: Nikki White would have been far better off if only she had been a convicted bank robber.
Nikki was a slim and athletic college graduate who had health insurance, had worked in health care and knew the system. But she had systemic lupus erythematosus, a chronic inflammatory disease that was diagnosed when she was 21 and gradually left her too sick to work. And once she lost her job, she lost her health insurance.
In any other rich country, Nikki probably would have been fine, notes T. R. Reid in his important and powerful new book, “The Healing of America.” Some 80 percent of lupus patients in the United States live a normal life span. Under a doctor’s care, lupus should be manageable. Indeed, if Nikki had been a felon, the problem could have been averted, because courts have ruled that prisoners are entitled to medical care.
As Mr. Reid recounts, Nikki tried everything to get medical care, but no insurance company would accept someone with her pre-existing condition. She spent months painfully writing letters to anyone she thought might be able to help. She fought tenaciously for her life.
Finally, Nikki collapsed at her home in Tennessee and was rushed to a hospital emergency room, which was then required to treat her without payment until her condition stabilized. Since money was no longer an issue, the hospital performed 25 emergency surgeries on Nikki, and she spent six months in critical care.
“When Nikki showed up at the emergency room, she received the best of care, and the hospital spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on her,” her step-father, Tony Deal, told me. “But that’s not when she needed the care.”
By then it was too late. In 2006, Nikki White died at age 32. “Nikki didn’t die from lupus,” her doctor, Amylyn Crawford, told Mr. Reid. “Nikki died from complications of the failing American health care system.”
“She fell through the cracks,” Nikki’s mother, Gail Deal, told me grimly. “When you bury a child, it’s the worst thing in the world. You never recover.”
We now have a chance to reform this cruel and capricious system. If we let that chance slip away, there will be another Nikki dying every half-hour.
That’s how often someone dies in America because of a lack of insurance, according to a study by a branch of the National Academy of Sciences. Over a year, that amounts to 18,000 American deaths.
After Al Qaeda killed nearly 3,000 Americans, eight years ago on Friday, we went to war and spent hundreds of billions of dollars ensuring that this would not happen again. Yet every two months, that many people die because of our failure to provide universal insurance — and yet many members of Congress want us to do nothing?
Mr. Reid’s book is a rich tour of health care around the world. Because he has a bum shoulder, he asked doctors in many countries to examine it and make recommendations. His American orthopedist recommended a titanium shoulder replacement that would cost tens of thousands of dollars and might or might not help. Specialists in other countries warned that a sore shoulder didn’t justify the risks of such major surgery, although some said it would be available free if Mr. Reid insisted. Instead, they offered physical therapy, acupuncture and other cheap and noninvasive alternatives, some of which worked pretty well.
That’s a window into the flaws in our health care system: we offer titanium shoulder replacements for those who don’t really need them, but we let 32-year-old women die if they lose their health insurance. No wonder we spend so much on medical care, and yet have some health care statistics that are worse than Slovenia’s.
My suggestion for anyone in Nikki’s situation: commit a crime and get locked up. In Washington State, a 20-year-old inmate named Melissa Matthews chose to turn down parole and stay in prison because that was the only way she could get treatment for her cervical cancer. “If I’m out, I’m going to die from this cancer,” she told a television station.
Mr. and Mrs. Deal say they are speaking out because Nikki wouldn’t want anyone to endure what she did. “Nikki was a college-educated, middle-class woman, and if it could happen to her, it can happen to anyone,” Mr. Deal said. “This should not be happening in our country.”
Struggling to get out the words, Mrs. Deal added: “The loss of a child is the greatest hurt anyone will ever suffer. Because of the circumstances she endured with the health care system, I lost my daughter.”
Complex arguments are being batted around in this health care debate, but the central issue isn’t technical but moral. The first question is simply this: Do we wish to be the only rich nation in the world that lets a 32-year-old woman die because she can’t get health insurance? Is that really us?
I invite you to comment on this column on my blog, On the Ground. Please also join me on Facebook, watch my YouTube videos and follow me on Twitter.Thursday, September 10, 2009
Welcome Baby Taylor Grace!
We already have socialized medicine, just not for everyone
from God's Politics, a blog by Jim Wallis and friends
Why the U.S. Ranks 37 Among World Health Systems, Plus Four Alternative Models
by Valerie Elverton Dixon 09-09-2009The United States is the richest nation on earth. It has some of the best-trained physicians and best medical facilities on earth. It is a leader in medical innovation and medical education. However, when the World Health Organization studied the health-care systems of some 191 countries, the U.S. ranked 37. Under the leadership of Dr. Christopher Murray of Harvard University and Julio Frenk, former health minister in Mexico, the WHO analyzed financing, organization operations, and availability of care in different systems. Its 2000 report, which was intended to help countries improve their health care systems, found the United States far behind its industrialized peers.
This information comes from T.R. Reid, a Washington Post correspondent and bestselling author, in his recent book The Healing of America. In this book Reid compares and contrasts the American health-care system with those of other nations. He presented some of his findings in a documentary for the PBS series Frontline.
What Reid found can go a long way toward informing our thinking about the urgent need for health-care reform in the United States. There is a measure called Disability-Adjusted Life Expectancy (DALE) that measures “healthy life expectancy.” This comes about through a healthy lifestyle and the access to medical care for both the prevention and cure of illness. The U.S. ranks 24 according to the DALE measure (70 years). This is lower than Israel and ahead of Cyprus. According to Reid the U.S. received this ranking because it fails to provide access to basic health care for some 45 million people.
In his book, he describes four basic models of care:
1. In the Bismarck system, private insurers and private providers with employers and employees pay the premiums. In most countries that use it, everyone is covered and insurance companies are highly regulated and are prevented from making a profit on basic health care. Government pays for those who are unemployed. This corresponds to the kind of insurance most working people in the U.S. have.
2. In the Beveridge system, government owns the health-care facilities, most providers are government employees, and the government pays all the bills. This corresponds to the Veterans Administration system in the United States.
3. In the National Health Insurance model, the medical facilities and providers are private, but the government pays for the services. This corresponds to Medicare in the U.S.
4. Then there is the out-of-pocket system. Those who have money get health care and those who do not have money do not get health care. This is the case for the 45 million uninsured in the U.S.
So, in our public discourse, when we worry about “socialized” medicine coming to the U.S. and dealing a death blow to our freedoms, let us remember that we already have “socialized” medicine for military personnel, veterans, Native Americans, everyone over 65, and the poor. Part of the problem with our system is that it is not a unified system, and there is no equality built into it. And to think that the emergency room answers the problem is also deeply mistaken.
Reid tells us that the industrialized nations who made a decision to provide universal health care to their citizens first made a moral decision. They decided that basic health care ought not to be a for-profit enterprise, and they based their moral decision on a value that defined them as a people. For France and Switzerland the value was solidarity. What moral value does the health-care system in the United States demonstrate?
Dr. Valerie Elverton Dixon is an independent scholar who publishes lectures and essays at JustPeaceTheory.com. She received her Ph.D. in religion and society from Temple University and taught Christian ethics at United Theological Seminary and Andover Newton Theological School.
Friday, September 4, 2009
Greg's Arguments for Health Care Reform
Why I'm for universal health care
by Greg Carey
Read more of Greg's stuff here http://ntgeeks.blogspot.com
1. I believe in community responsibility, rather than radical individualism. If a disabled child can't reach the toys, I believe you have to move the toys -- even if it costs a little to build a new toy box. I can't separate this conviction from my Christian outlook, in which the least of these take priority over my individual prerogatives.
2. The United States has done some wonderful things collaboratively. We created a public school system that was the envy of the world. We built an incredible highway system. We turned the Tennessee River from a scary flood machine into a source of affordable energy. We can respond to epidemics in unbelievable ways. Flawed as it is, our public university system remains the world's most innovative and productive. If we decide we have a common interest, we can do pretty much anything.
3. Did you know that the USA spends nearly twice as much per person on medical care than any other nation in the world?
4. And yet (did you know) that our health outcomes are among the worst in the G20? We're talking life expectancy, infant mortality, and so forth. We're #19, I believe.
5. Our peer nations all have affordable health care for everyone (and remember, with better overall outcomes). Most of their citizens believe, as I do, that it's an affluent society's duty to provide basic housing, education, and medical care to all their citizens. Most of them think we're nuts.
6. Unless you're genuinely rich, a medical crisis could ruin you financially.
7. I do not believe private is superior to public, or that the marketplace outperforms public, on this issue. Did you know that Medicare outperforms employment based private insurance in terms of customer satisfaction and access to care?* And the VA is in the top four overall plans?+ The thing is, we already have rationed health care. All health care is rationed. The problem is, our health care is rationed by people who have no interest in our health.
* http://tpmcafe.talkingpoin
+ http://www.reuters.com/art